top of page

A warning to the 80/20 Pareto Principle

Nov 3
4 min read
A warning to the 80/20 Principle
A warning to the 80/20 Principle

I will assume that everyone who reads my blog knows the Pareto Principle. Well, maybe not 100% of everyone, maybe 80%, and of those 80%, 20% read it routinely. The Pareto Principle, also known as the 80/20 rule or the law of the vital few, states that 80% of consequences come from 20% of causes. If you intentionally look for the 80/20, you will see it showing up everywhere.


The principle suggests you wear 20% of the clothes you own 80% of the time. It might explain why, when you are down to 20% of the gas in your tank, you suddenly become much more attentive to finding a gas station. The principle suggests that 20% of your Facebook friends populate 80% of the posts you see. In high schools, data suggests that 80% of the discipline issues come from 20% of the students.


80/20 - Pareto Principle


In manufacturing, 80/20 exists in OEE and asset reliability. The 80/20 rule would suggest that 20% of your assets cause 80% of your pain. Or, conversely, that 80% of your time is not being consumed by the 20% of the assets. Paying attention to this phenomenon could align a team around the problems that are eating your lunch and ruining your evenings.


Historically, I have seen this Pareto breakdown align organizations to routinely focus on the latest problem at hand. You focus your team's collective actions, root cause failure analysis, and equipment blitzes on moving those assets out of the top 20% of your problems. Your teams are strong, relentless, and intentional about getting those problems resolved so they can move on to the latest emergent issues based on the data. Rinse. Repeat. Rinse. Repeat. There is satisfaction in watching an asset move down the Pareto chart and eventually fall below the 20% cutoff. You have made progress, and the data tells you so.


Here is where I think we can get ourselves into trouble with the Pareto Principle.


What the 80/20 Pareto Principle might miss


Consider the 80/20 principle with those high school students. You are focused on the 20% of individuals creating 80% of the discipline issues. With extra attention to detail, specific discipline, and structure, you have successfully moved some of them out of your top 20%. Proud and happy to see them move out, new ones emerge and become the latest focus. You are now concentrating on the latest top 20% because the principle and the data tell you to. Remaining relentless, focused, and determined on the next group, you want to see these students improve as well. Meanwhile, some of those who dropped out of the original 20% are just priming to rejoin because you haven't built the resilience or sustained the habits necessary to keep them from returning.

Vilfredo Pareto is an Italian economist who is credited with coining the term the 80/20 principle. That is, 80% of results are driven by 20% of effort. Ferriss claims that each of us should revisit the 80/20 principle every four weeks and apply it to both our work and personal lives to see how we can focus on maximizing our productive output/ - Ryan Ablett, Medium

The challenge I see when managing assets is that these 20% offenders move off the list, but the actions you put in place to correct the problems might not be sustainable. We celebrate getting them out of the top 20% and quickly move our attention and resources elsewhere. We assume the problem has been resolved. Instead, perhaps we should look at those assets as the high school student who is on probation and still being monitored. You continue to invest a little time to ensure that student doesn't rejoin the 20%, through encouragement, direction, and a continued expectation to stay focused.


Assets require the same attention. They need what I would call a monitoring or probationary period, where we continue to pay attention long enough to establish whether the corrective actions have actually taken hold. The objective isn't simply to get an asset off the Pareto chart, but to make sure the reasons it was there in the first place have been addressed in a sustainable way.


I have seen situations where an issue that once consumed a significant portion of our OEE losses was addressed, improved, and eventually disappeared from the top of the Pareto. Only to find it rejoining the list later. The original corrective actions had moved the needle, but they had not necessarily changed the underlying behaviors, practices, or conditions enough to sustain the improvement. We had celebrated the departure without ensuring that it was permanent.


Don't get trapped by the Pareto Principle or Pareto Law


Don't get trapped by the Pareto Principle. It is a fantastic tool to drive strategy, growth, and waste elimination. It helps us determine where to focus our energy and resources, and there is no question that organizations need that discipline. However, too often we put all our energy into the problems above the cut and forget about the ones that have just moved below it.


The 20% below the cut still deserve some attention. Not necessarily the same level of attention or the same resources, but enough to ensure that the improvement sticks. Otherwise, you may find yourself fighting the same battle again, wondering why something you thought you had already fixed has managed to work its way back into your top 20%.

Sometimes the biggest improvement isn't getting another problem off the Pareto. It is making sure the last one you removed doesn't come back.

​

Comments


©2021 OpEmpathy.com

bottom of page